Quack Economic Doctors

Suppose you go to a doctor. You are in pain and you tell him that you feel like you are going to die. He takes your temperature, and sees that it is a perfectly normal 98.6F. He tells you to go home, you must be fine. He does not seem to be aware of any problem that can cause pain but not a fever (e.g. a broken vertebra, cancer, or bleeding). He is a quack.

It’s a good thing that real doctors have many diagnostics and indicators. They are not limited to just body temperature.

Let’s turn our attention to the monetary system. The quacks focus their attention on prices. The rate of change of prices—which they improperly define as inflation—is the monetary equivalent of body temperature in medicine. In some cases, it’s an important part of making a diagnosis.

And it is far from the only indicator.

If prices are like temperature, then what is analogous to the patient’s pulse? Interest rates. And interest rates have been falling for 34 years.

Is there a doctor in the house? Should we be worried?

3 thoughts on “Quack Economic Doctors


    I always thought that the official indicator of inflation is the Consumer Price Index (CPI), And, as you know, monetary policy influences prices and therefore inflation.

    1. Keith Weiner Post author

      Joe, I call it the greatest sleight of hand. To misdirect attention to prices, and call that “inflation”.

      My definition of inflation has nothing to do with prices, nor the presumed cause: the money supply (we don’t have money in the monetary system–gold–it’s all credit). I define inflation as an expansion of counterfeit credit. Monetary fraud. One possible consequence of inflation is rising prices. Another is flat prices. A third is falling prices.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s